Here is the Low Down on your Hop Up Buckling ( Rubber ),
The difference between a standard and a tuning Buckling is the quality of the Product, your after market or tuning Bucklings on the average are of a better quality Rubber, and have Fans ( added nipples ) inside of the Buckling. The Fans allow for a better and finer adjustment.
Don´t go getting wrapped around the axel about using a Soft or Hard Buckling, alot of different variables come into play first i.e., BB Weight, Quality of BB, Consistancy of FPS, outside Temp., Humidity. It is a process of trial and error, you may find that you will have better results using a Soft Buckling, shooting 550FPS in cold or humid weather with .35g BB´s, or a Hard Buckling, shooting 350FPS in Hot Dry weather with .25g BB´s.
A great buckling will increase your accuracy and range when used with quality BB´s.
As far as the Hop-Up assembly, Metal does not mean Better. The main reason for a metal Hop-Up is not Durability, it´s survivability. If you should happen to `` Punch Out ´´ a GB, the plastic will not survive the impact of the piston, a metal one will ( In most cases ).
All Hop-Up´s suffer from the same problems, not holding the Hop, resetting, it dosn´t matter if it is Plastic or Metal. A few simple tricks to remove the problem, replace the metal washers with rubber ones, add an extra washer, loosen the set screw when adjusting the Hop-Up, a drop of Screw Set ( similar to Lock Tight ), on the Hop-Up adjustment wheel when Hop is correct.
Who makes the best ?? This can be argued, it all comes down to personal favorites, some like Prometheus ( Lay-Lax ), others Mad Bull Sharks, TM Hard and so on, IMHO the very best is the Kurage Spicy, they last forever, work amazingly in either Low FPS or High ( to include Extreme) FPS ranges, the only problem is finding them.
Hope this helps.